Who has the best auto insurance rates in NJ?
NJM is a bit cheaper than GEICO in most categories we reviewed. A notable exception is teen drivers, who received a lower rate from GEICO. *Note: These are average, annual costs. Your costs may vary.
Cheapest by category | Company | Average monthly rate |
---|---|---|
Large company | State Farm | $39 |
Midsize company | American National | $27 |
After a speeding ticket | State Farm | $46 |
After an accident | State Farm | $51 |
NJM is a bit cheaper than GEICO in most categories we reviewed. A notable exception is teen drivers, who received a lower rate from GEICO. *Note: These are average, annual costs. Your costs may vary.
Compare quotes. In New Jersey, drivers spend an average of $211 per month and $2,538 annually on full-coverage car insurance and $111 per month and $1,334 per year on liability-only coverage. By comparison, the national monthly average for full coverage is $212 and $103 for liability.
With an average rate of $95 a month for full coverage, Geico wins as the best car insurance in NJ for your wallet in 2024. That's the cheapest car insurance rate among our list of top-rated insurers. Geico also offers a host of car insurance discounts drivers may qualify for.
The annual average cost of car insurance in New Jersey is $1,754 for full coverage and $782 for minimum coverage.
Key Takeaways: The cheapest overall company for full-coverage car insurance policies is Nationwide at $1,428 annually or $119 per month. USAA and Geico are also affordable options for full-coverage car insurance. Regional providers like Erie Insurance can have cheap rates, however they aren't available everywhere.
State Farm is the largest auto insurance company in the U.S., with 17% of the market. Other big car insurance companies include Progressive, Geico and Allstate. Currently insured? It's free, simple and secure.
Driving record
If you have a clean record, you might end up paying 40% less than drivers with a poor record, thanks in part to the availability of safe-driver discounts. But you're likely to be charged more if you make a lot of insurance claims, whether or not the accidents are your fault.
Key Points: Geico's full coverage costs an average of $1,572 per year, which is around 38 percent cheaper than Allstate's full coverage rate of $2,520 per year. Allstate offers more flexible roadside assistance packages than Geico, but both companies charge a fee for the service, either monthly, annually, or per-use.
Is NJM good insurance?
With 4.6/5 stars in 2024, NJM is an above-average insurance company. Read NJM reviews, complaints and prices before you buy.
Filing a claim won't necessarily affect your premium. A claim is one of several personalized factors used in determining an auto premium. We will review the claim details carefully at the time of your renewal.
- Nationwide. Best for policy customization. ...
- USAA. Best for military associates. ...
- Auto-Owners. Best rates. ...
- Travelers. Best for new car owners. ...
- American Family. Excellent complaint record with state insurance departments. ...
- Progressive. Best online features. ...
- Erie. Best for claims satisfaction. ...
- Geico. Best for SR-22 drivers.
Why is car insurance so expensive in New Jersey? While it's not the most expensive state for car insurance in the country, New Jersey still ranks 45th for affordability. Car insurance is likely higher due to traffic levels in urban areas, proximity to other major cities and the number of claims in the state.
Cheapest Minimum Liability Car Insurance in New Jersey (February 2024) The following carriers offer the cheapest average auto insurance premiums, according to the state minimum requirements: GEICO: $478 per year. Plymouth Rock Assurance: $484 per year.
NJM offers very affordable full-coverage car insurance. At $140 per month, full coverage from NJM is 15% cheaper than the national average. Although State Farm has cheaper rates for full coverage, drivers may find NJM's extra coverage perks worth the additional $16 per month.
State Farm and Progressive are both excellent insurance companies and compare favorably to others in their industry. Both have high ratings for financial strength, offer multiple coverage options and discounts, and rate near or above average in most third-party reviews of car insurance companies.
Allstate, for example, secured auto insurance rate hikes in New York (14.6%), California (30%) and New Jersey (17%) that went into effect in December. In 2024, the company is pushing for rate increases in at least 10 states, including additional hikes in New York and Jersey, executives said on a recent earnings call.
The average rate for full coverage auto insurance in New Jersey is $1,492 per year or $124 per month, which is expensive compared to other states nationwide. It ranks 45th out of 50 states in affordability.
Is $100 a month for car insurance good? Our cost estimates show that 35-year-old married drivers with good credit and clean driving records pay an average of $144 per month for car insurance. Paying around $100 per month for quality auto coverage is a good deal.
How much of my paycheck should go to car insurance?
According to our research, you shouldn't spend more than 10% to 15% of your net monthly income on car payments. Your total vehicle costs, including loan payments and insurance, should total no more than 20%. You can use a car loan calculator to calculate a monthly payment within your budget.
Is USAA Only for Military? Yes, USAA is only available to active and retired military members and their families. This includes active-duty, former military, cadets, widows, current or un-remarried spouses, and children.
- Shop around. ...
- Before you buy a car, compare insurance costs. ...
- Ask for higher deductibles. ...
- Reduce coverage on older cars. ...
- Buy your homeowners and auto coverage from the same insurer. ...
- Maintain a good credit record. ...
- Take advantage of low mileage discounts. ...
- Ask about group insurance.
Several factors are driving up the cost of car insurance, including lingering issues from the pandemic. Vehicles are more expensive and costlier to replace, with inflation driving up the cost of computer components and other parts required for repairs.
Car Insurance Provider | National Market Share | Overall Rating Out of 10.0* |
---|---|---|
1. State Farm | 16.84% | 9.4 |
2. Geico | 14.05% | 9.1 |
3. Progressive | 13.76% | 9 |
4. Allstate | 10.69% | 8.8 |